Selecting the Best Marketing Attribution Tool
What is Marketing Attribution?
In short, Marketing Attribution is the process of evaluating the marketing touchpoints a consumer encounters on their path to purchase. It then assigns value or credit to a set of advertisement impressions that contribute to a desired outcome (Example: conversions). To read more about how Marketing Attribution works, see OptiMine’s informative post here.
Options and Approaches to Marketing Attribution
Today’s marketing attribution approaches range from the most basic and simplistic all the way to highly sophisticated platforms. Most rely on a combination of clicks, cookies, consumer and device tracking and PII. For a complete summary of today’s marketing attribution options, see this informative overview that OptiMine recently published.
Key Marketing Attribution Considerations
Like any marketing measurement approach, there are many considerations to keep in mind as you seek the best tool for the job at hand. With marketing attribution, there are some serious challenges to keep front and center, whether you already have an attribution solution deployed or are looking to implement a new one:
With data loss due to cookie death but also importantly due to Apple’s iOS / ATT privacy changes which has caused approximately 40% of the mobile advertising space in the US to go dark. And the data loss trend will continue: Apple’s MPP has already caused significant portions of the email tracking space to go dark, and Google’s FLoC initiative will stop all individual targeting and tracking in 2023. One thing is clear: data loss is going to get a lot worse over the next 1-2 years.
Why does this matter for marketing attribution? Even small data gaps (e.g. mis-matches or gaps between identifying who was exposed to an ad and whether they converted) throw giant accuracy problems into marketing attribution models that rely on identity tracking.
Major new consumer privacy regulations in the US (California, Colorado, Virginia plus about 12 more states on the way) have introduced significant new risks to brands that capture, store, share, sell and use personally identifiable information (“PII”).
Why does this matter for marketing attribution? If your brand uses consumer data tracking at the core of your marketing attribution, you have significant new risks and complexities as a result of these regulations, even if you use a 3rd party vendor.
There are many hidden, and costly, expenses when deploying a tracking-based marketing attribution solution- costs that many brands may not originally factor into the TCO of the attribution solution:
- Marketing attribution solution licensing fees: this is the expense most brands focus on, and licensing costs for a marketing attribution solution can be significant, but are only one part of the cost picture.
- 3rd party identity data licenses, processing costs: a brand must also license, access and store identity data and pay for processing their own customer data to match third party identity graphs. Note: this expense is triggered when a brand chooses an attribution solution that relies on consumer tracking.
- Integration and ongoing maintenance expense: the web design team placing pixels, tracking code and building out back-end customer data integrations is only part of the expense. When the brand decides to ask a different question, measure a new KPI or track differently, these expenses often multiply.
- Regulatory compliance costs: If a consumer in California decides to exercise their new right “to be forgotten” from a data privacy standpoint, the brand must comply and be able to demonstrate that this request has been fully honored. How many systems, vendors and databases does your brand have that house, use or leverage PII? Complying with the simple request to remove this PII data isn’t so simple, and isn’t “free”.
Technical Inflexibility (AKA “Brittleness”)
When using a tracking-based marketing attribution platform, if the data you decide to collect doesn’t change, things are a little easier to manage. But the reality is that brands are dynamic businesses reacting to new market pressures, evolving product strategies and consumer choices & demands. The probability that what a brand’s marketing team measures will remain static over time is nearly zero. A hidden cost of new questions, KPIs and data sources is that the brand must re-tag digital assets, collect new types of data, and recalibrate (or in most cases build new) models. This is hard. And is a significant hidden expense for marketing attribution solutions.
Selecting a Marketing Attribution Tool
Build vs. Buy
One primary consideration when looking for a new marketing attribution solution is to consider building a solution internally vs. licensing a solution from a vendor in the market. How to weigh your options?
Think about your analytic resources and staffing levels first. Does your analytics team have available capacity to develop an in-house solution? Does your brand have the requisite data science, predictive modeling and data engineering skills and experience to build a custom solution? Lastly, are there other high-priority projects, deliverables or efforts that will be stopped as a result of a dedicated in-house build? One rule of thumb to keep in mind: it may take an experienced team upwards of 9-12 months to build a capable measurement solution, and will require continuous “care and feeding” once built. This is not a simple, quick one-time project. And if your brand must hire new resources to put towards such an effort, consider the costs of hiring and compensating new staff vs. the license expense of a 3rd party vendor solution.
When considering a vendor solution in the market, start with a well defined set of requirements first. Does your brand use both digital and traditional advertising channels? Most marketing attribution solutions only focus on digital channels. Does your brand have both online and offline conversions? Again, most attribution solutions only measure online conversions. Lastly, is you brand (and compliance group) comfortable with the use of PII (and the data loss & accuracy issues that come with PII) for an attribution solution? Most, but not all, attribution vendors require the use of PII for their solutions.
Beware of Relying Solely on Marketing Platforms & Publishers
Many brands simply rely on the measurement tools available from the Walled Gardens, their advertising agencies, or from publisher / ad network platforms. Brands must also recognize the inherent conflict of interest involved in relying on these sources of measurement: they are “grading their own homework”. Skeptical of this? Try this exercise: add up the “credit” for all campaigns across these various platforms, partners and tools. If the “credit” exceeds the actual amount of your brand’s revenues, you’ve now confirmed the issue. (Hint: most brands have 3-6X actual revenues when they go through this exercise).
Key Criteria to Evaluate
|Criteria||Important Notes & Considerations|
Does the solution cover all of the marketing channels for your brand (including traditional media such as TV, radio, print, OOH)?
Does the solution cover all of the conversion channels for your brand (including in-app, in-store, call center, branch locations, sales agents, in addition to e-commerce)?
Controlling for Non-Marketing Factors
Does the modeling solution account and control for non-marketing factors (weather, seasonality, competition, economy) as well as your brand’s own non-marketing impacts (promotions, discounts, PR, events, sponsorships)?
Avoiding Reliance on PII
Does the solution require PII? Can the solution provide detailed campaign-level measures without the use of PII?
Need for Speed
Does the solution require data integrations, use of 3rd party data onboarding, tagging digital assets, matching offline consumer data, or other data-related tasks that greatly slow down deployments and updates over time?
How easy can the solution change to new KPIs or conversion outcomes? How fast and easy is it to add new channels and data? How long must the solution recalibrate models when data changes? How long does it take to build new models? How often are the predictive models updated?
Does the solution require additional expenses for data, data integration, web development, compliance costs, and IT costs?
OptiMine provides several advantages over traditional consumer tracking-based approaches to attribution such as Multi-Touch Attribution (“MTA”). And when brands seek a more future-proof approach to attribution that doesn’t use PII (for example, traditional Marketing Mix Modeling or, “MMM”), there are even more tradeoffs and weaknesses that OptiMine helps leading brands overcome.
A Future-Proof Marketing Attribution Tool:
We’re now well into a major era of privacy-driven data disruption. Attribution approaches that require PII are no longer safe, accurate nor reliable moving forward. OptiMine’s approach uses no PII data whatsoever and delivers a 100% future-proof solution for brands.
Speed matters now more than ever. The brands with the best intelligence combined with speed will outperform those brands who lag in these areas. OptiMine delivers the fastest solution in the market, providing the quickest ramp to ROI, and promises speed and flexibility for the long haul.
Comprehensive Cross-Channel Measurement & Optimization:
The days of having to combine MTA and marketing mix modeling (“MMM”) solutions to get complete marketing and conversion coverage are over. OptiMine provides a truly unified measurement and optimization solution that covers both traditional and digital marketing across online and offline conversions all in one single solution and modeling methodology. No more conflicting answers, measurement gaps, and solution complexity. OptiMine is the only truly unified solution in the market. Period.
See below an outline of the many advantages OptiMine provides when considering a marketing attribution solution:
Interested in learning more about how OptiMine’s marketing attribution tools can help you? Contact us today!
- “What is Marketing Mix Modeling (MMM)?” Blog Post
- “What is Incrementality in Marketing?” Blog Post
- “Marketing Attribution FAQ” Blog Post
- OptiMine On-Demand Webinar: “Apple’s ATT Changes Are Now Live. Learn How It’s Impacting Brands’ Measurement, Performance, & How to Move Forward”